Discover Nikkei Logo

https://www.discovernikkei.org/en/interviews/clips/253/

Testing assumptions of Japanese scholars

You know, I was kind of concerned about the Japanese scholars studying the Japanese American experience, and trying to caution them to be careful about the assumptions underlying their framework. And I think it’s very important that they do these studies because they can tell you a lot from their perspective.

But, I was saying to them, for us it’s a matter of perspective and a matter of getting our own perspective on our own identity. And I says, “If you were looking for answers to the question of your own identity, would you start out with, suppose, Ruth Benedict’s Chrysanthemum and the Sword?” I said, “That was done during the wartime with a very eminent anthropologist interviewing Japanese Americans about the Japanese identity.” And I says, “If you really wanted to get a line on your own identity, would you start out with a book like that?” I says, “It’s important for you to look at that book, but I’d certainly start out from your own perspective.” I says, “Your experiences in Japan and your scholarship training have various kinds of assumptions, so that if you’re studying the immigrant population of the Japanese all over the world, then test your own assumptions.”


education identity Japanese Americans

Date: January 7, 2004

Location: California, US

Interviewer: Art Hansen

Contributed by: Watase Media Arts Center, Japanese American National Museum.

Interviewee Bio

James Hirabayashi, son of hardworking immigrant farmers in the Pacific Northwest, was a high school senior in 1942 when he was detained in the Pinedale Assembly Center before being transferred to the Tule Lake Concentration Camp in Northern California.

After World War II, he earned his Bachelor of Arts and Masters in Anthropology from the University of Washington, and eventually his Ph.D. from Harvard University. Dr. Hirabayashi is Professor Emeritus at San Francisco State University where he was Dean of the nation’s first school of ethnic studies. He also held research and teaching positions at the University of Tokyo, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, and Ahmadu Bellow Univerity, Zaria, Nigeria.

He passed away in May 2012 at age 85. (June 2014)

George Ariyoshi
en
ja
es
pt

Teacher who helped with lisp

(b.1926) Democratic politician and three-term Governor of Hawai'i

en
ja
es
pt
Steve Kaji
en
ja
es
pt

FOB's

Hawaii born Nikkei living in Japan. English Teacher at YMCA.

en
ja
es
pt
Barbara Kawakami
en
ja
es
pt

Kids working hard

An expert researcher and scholar on Japanese immigrant clothing.

en
ja
es
pt
Barbara Kawakami
en
ja
es
pt

First day of school

An expert researcher and scholar on Japanese immigrant clothing.

en
ja
es
pt
Eric Morton
en
ja
es
pt

Addressing multiracial identity can be difficult

Starred at wide receiver for Dartmouth College, now a patent attorney. Brother of Johnnie and Chad Morton.

en
ja
es
pt
Ann K. Nakamura
en
ja
es
pt

Image of Americans

Sansei from Hawaii living in Japan. Teacher and businesswoman.

en
ja
es
pt
Robert (Bob) Kiyoshi Okasaki
en
ja
es
pt

Grandmother's influence on decision to go to Japan

(b.1942) Japanese American ceramist, who has lived in Japan for over 30 years.

en
ja
es
pt
Robert (Bob) Kiyoshi Okasaki
en
ja
es
pt

Band-Aid realization

(b.1942) Japanese American ceramist, who has lived in Japan for over 30 years.

en
ja
es
pt
Robert (Bob) Kiyoshi Okasaki
en
ja
es
pt

Japanese influence growing up

(b.1942) Japanese American ceramist, who has lived in Japan for over 30 years.

en
ja
es
pt
Robert (Bob) Kiyoshi Okasaki
en
ja
es
pt

Looking at your country from the outside

(b.1942) Japanese American ceramist, who has lived in Japan for over 30 years.

en
ja
es
pt
Robert (Bob) Kiyoshi Okasaki
en
ja
es
pt

Wife's family in Japan

(b.1942) Japanese American ceramist, who has lived in Japan for over 30 years.

en
ja
es
pt
Yukio Takeshita
en
ja
es
pt

Lack of notion of citizenship in Japan

(b.1935) American born Japanese. Retired businessman.

en
ja
es
pt
Yukio Takeshita
en
ja
es
pt

Involvement in JACL

(b.1935) American born Japanese. Retired businessman.

en
ja
es
pt
Jane Aiko Yamano
en
ja
es
pt

Lack of language skills

(b.1964) California-born business woman in Japan. A successor of her late grandmother, who started a beauty business in Japan.

en
ja
es
pt
Jane Aiko Yamano
en
ja
es
pt

Having patience in Japan, being both

(b.1964) California-born business woman in Japan. A successor of her late grandmother, who started a beauty business in Japan.

en
ja
es
pt

Discover Nikkei Updates

DISCOVER NIKKEI PROGRAM
July 12 • Burnaby, British Columbia
Join us for a book talk, reception, and panel discussion on Japanese Canadian history. The panel discussion will also be live-streamed via Zoom!
NIKKEI CHRONICLES #14
Nikkei Family 2: Remembering Roots, Leaving Legacies
Baachan, grandpa, tía, irmão… what does Nikkei family mean to you? Submit your story!
SUPPORT THE PROJECT
Discover Nikkei’s 20 for 20 campaign celebrates our first 20 years and jumpstarts our next 20. Learn more and donate!